Saturday, September 27, 2008

LIVE Blog --- Presidential Debate #1 HIGHLIGHTS

Well, first off, let me say that I intended on being ready to start taking notes during the "pre-game show"...but it took me until 6:15 PST to rush home in time to have missed that first five minutes. Luckily for us, it was a knock=down, drag-out 96-minute prizefight... the old man playing "champion" to the democrat's "challenger" throughout most of moderator Jim Lehrer's questioning.

Before I give you a few samples of the minute-by-minute analysis; let me tell you a little bit about the personalities revealed last night during America's biggest "job interview."
The event revealed a fire in McCain; a never-ending burn that might have began back in Vietnam. The one that will never go away, the one of one who knows what the whole world faces; and not just the United States, on a daily basis. It says that he understands how terrorists play politics. It says that just when you think your safe; he knows the pieces do not yet fit. It revealed his ability to recognize the feelings that go with losing a war; to show how few Americans understand such a concept.
It revealed his frustration with an America raging with idealism in an attempt to make Americans "understand" how much we "have to fear" in terms of how little our overseas allies even think of us. He seemed to believe that Obama represents this false ideology that represents what we all want..but John McCain doesnt believe is easily accessible.
McCain: "I believe America is better off now than it was on 9/11/"
Obama: "I believe America is less respected than it was 8 years ago."
Obama made it very clear that he and McCain esseentially want the same things. Being what Obama wants isn't terribly realistic to Republicans; the spin room began preparing next week's debate to make it look like a battle of logistics vs. practical revolutionaries. Now let's look for a bit at a few minutes of the debate itself:
6:
18: McCain's response to a question about taxes:"I didn't win Ms. Congeniality in the Senate."
22: McCain questions Obama's definition of "rich" in tax code terms: $250,000/year or less would mean untaxed under Obama. (He then later said this was 95% of Americans.)
23: Earmark issues come up with Obama attacking McCain's earmark approval record. McCain turns it right around on him and cites legislation he signed which would have raised average taxes $2000 + per family. Obama: "It's just not true." I gotta admit I wished he had come back with clarified specific examples.
25: McCain looks down at his podium again while Obama answers confidently to the camera and the eyes of moderator Jim Lehrer. I know what this feeling is like. I too have skipped homework. This paints the picture of an uneducated child in an old man's angry bitter beaten body. Hardly a professional patriot prepared for philosophical battle.
27: Obama points out health care deductibles went up 30% for the average American this year.
28: He then talks of infrastructure rebuilding plans for his presidential budget. McCain blasts Obama's spending record saying "Obama has the most liberal record in the Senate. It's impossible for someone with his record to swing all the way to the right and compromise across partylines."
29 McCain points to the Senate where a number of high-spending bills were approved then shelved when even the big spenders realized there was a big problem with the logistics of spending. Calls out Obama's history of fiscal irresponsibility.
31 Obama's first response: "Me being liberal is just fighting George Bush's wacky policy." Great stuff.
32 I notice Obama keeps saying "When I become President..."
33 McCain's attack on Obama's record grows..McCain suggests a spending freeze with the exception of emergency..military and defense costs always covered.
33 Obama responds by taking money from the military; distributing those funds elsewhere/
34 McCain finishes his spending plan by proposing nuke plants in America..as many as 30 by 2030.
35 McCain says "I want Americans to decide (on) their health care programs. Not the government." (Editor's Note: I, for one, Mr. McCain, need help getting health care. Whatcha gonna do about me?") "I have plans to reduce wasteful spending."
Obama: "But it was your man who supported this orgy of spending. After 8 years of frivolous spending Jim; John; that's a bit hard to swallow."
McCain: "I didnt win Ms. Congeniality in the Senate." GEE, that line sounds awful familiar.

Spending issues turn overseas and to the war. After 4000 deaths in Iraq, Obama claims Al-Qaeda is now back to being as strong as it was in 2001. Iraq stands today with a $75 billion surplus. Obama claims they need no further help or attention from us. Contends it is time to concentrate those efforts on our economy right here at home. There becomes a fundamental difference btwn the two from the perspective of who's winning the war, and where the war should be fought.
"The war on terrorism started in Afghanistan and should end (there)", Sen. Obama says. McCain responds by revealing Obama's responsibilities in the senate including a chairmanship of a sub-committee which keeps in contact with Gen. Petraeus monitoring the war. McCain claims Obama talks big but never once has used his position of power to create real dialogue with Gen. Petraeus and blasts Obama for never having visited Iraq.
McCain refuses to let the war go. He says it would mean that our kids may have to go back, and worse; it would mean to some that those 4000 soldiers have died in vain. He says Gen. Petraeus has measured our successes as "fragile", implying that if we were to just leave...it would undo everything done and quietly push the society into a further underground of terrorist operation.
Obama changes the subject a bit to conflicts with other outstanding countries. He brings up the idea of invading Pakistan on the way out of the middle east. McCain reacts as if this was literally out of left field by saying "You can't just SAY that. Ifyou have to , you do what you got to do. But you don't tell them." It follows the same logic fighting against a middle east exit date strategy.
Obama says that McCain can't feel seriously credible saying these kind of things when in the past he has said we should wipe North Korea into extinction and sang songs about bombing Iran.
The final 15 minutes are spent discussing philosophy and world views.

OPINION
Obama speaks to middle class America, proclaiming his intention to help those in need of a house loan, car payment, or the return of a deployed husband or wife or brother or sister at war.
McCain speaks to the rich and to the disillusioned military families of America who think that spoiled suit pockets like those of John McCain and George Bush are worth fighting for. He states that he'll "protect"them. He just wants to send them into harm's way.
I suppose we all see hear and feel different things at the end of the day when these speeches are over. I can only end by saying what I wish you heard for yourself and your country, was a hope that simply wasn't there yesterday. I'll be back next week for the 1st Vice Presidential Debate.

No comments: